Saturday 21 February 2015

Swansea comeback shows Van Gaal’s philosophy still not getting through

After claiming in the build-up to today’s match at the Liberty Stadium that his players were finally getting to grips with his philosophy, Louis Van Gaal watched on as his Manchester United side crashed to a 2-1 defeat against a Swansea side who completed a first-ever league double over the visitors from Old Trafford.

Despite taking the lead through a crisp Ander Herrera strike, United’s defensive frailties were once again exposed when Ki-Sung Yueng levelled almost immediately before a second half Jonjo Shelvey shot spun off the head of Bafetimbi Gomis to hand the Swans a famous win.

In truth, Garry Monk’s side barely done enough to merit all three points as United dominated the possession stakes but the Welsh outfit will no doubt point to a solid and steadfast defensive display which was marshalled by the impressive Ashley Williams.

However, the home side were helped by another disjointed display from United, particularly in attack, where the returning Robin Van Persie looked well off the pace while Wayne Rooney, who was restored to his preferred role up front, endured a frustrating afternoon in South Wales.

Herrera was perhaps the brightest of United’s front six in the first half as he scampered into space on a number of occasions, linking up with makeshift right back Paddy McNair, but the youngster’s end product disappointed all too often.

Meanwhile, on the other side, it was a role reversal as Luke Shaw looked threatening time and again as he attacked Swansea right back Kyle Naughton, but it was Angel Di Maria who was sloppy in possession.

The one time that it did click for United resulted in Herrera finding the same corner of the net as he did in Monday’s FA Cup win over Preston North End.

The Spaniard fired beautifully in off Lucas Fabianski’s right-hand post just before the half-hour mark after Di Maria and Rooney linked up following a fine run by Shaw.

That was the sole contribution from Di Maria, who, after a bright start to his career in Manchester following his £60million switch from Real Madrid, has struggled of late to provide any significant attacking thrust.

No doubt Van Gaal will have reddened around the cheeks just two minutes later though as not for the first time this season United switched off at the back to allow Shelvey to fire a low in-swinging cross into the penalty area where Ki - who scored in Swansea’s opening day win at Old Trafford in August - guided the ball passed the despairing David De Gea.

Bafetimbi Gomis inadvertently scored the winning goal as Swansea completed a league double over Manchester United


With Antonio Valencia replacing McNair at the break United continued to dominate possession in the second half but a familiar pattern emerged as the Red Devils huffed and puffed but could not find any rhythm in the final third.

Swans’ stopper Fabianski comfortably gathered a Van Persie effort after he had played a neat one-two with Rooney but the 31-year-old Dutchman’s afternoon was summed up by his final 10 minutes which saw him hobble about with an injured ankle as United had made all their substitutions.

Earlier Van Persie had fired into the side netting while also seeing an effort in the first half graze the top of the crossbar.

At the other end, life without departed top-scorer Wilfried Bony continued at the Liberty Stadium with Gomis now assuming the main striking role for Monk’s men.

The Frenchman looked lively, particularly in the opening 30 minutes, and was a constant thorn in the United defence with his pace and direct running.

Indeed, the former Lyon hitman should have scored twice with two close range headers from corners - the first cleared off the line by Herrera while the second sailed over De Gea’s crossbar.

However, Gomis’ head was to prove the deciding factor in the end as he guided the ball, albeit inadvertently, passed De Gea after Shelvey picked the ball up in oceans of space 25 yards out before letting fly in the 73rd minute.

The final 20 minutes of the game saw United desperately chase an equaliser by reverting to what is becoming an all too familiar Plan B - namely hump it up to Marouane Fellaini and hope to pick up the scraps.

Meat and drink to Williams and co.

Its back to the philosophical drawing board for Van Gaal and United. 


No comments:

Post a Comment